Leisure to Attend to Our Spiritual Business
Аннотация
Time is central to Martin Hägglund’s discussion of secular faith and spiritual freedom. Time is precisely what is finite in this life and presides over the relationships we value and our risk of losing them. Hägglund adopted the notion of disposable time from Karl Marx’s Grundrisse and reframed it as the more descriptive socially available free time. Following Marx, Hägglund advocates the revaluation of values so that socially available free time would become the measure of value rather than socially necessary labour time.
A close examination of the origin of Marx’s analysis of disposable time suggests that questions of faith and freedom were inherent in the concept as it was expressed in the 1821 pamphlet, The Source and Remedy of the National Difficulties that influenced Marx, in the writings of William Godwin that inspired the 1821 pamphlet, and ultimately in theological views on the doctrine of the calling that Godwin secularized in his pioneering advocacy of leisure as a universal human right.
Marx’s innovation was to show that the creation of disposable time is the basis of all wealth. Under capitalism, disposable time is expropriated in the form of surplus labour time, thereby inverting the relationship between necessary and superfluous labour time — the superfluous becomes necessary (for capital) and the necessary superfluous. Marx’s analysis of the inversion of necessary and superfluous labour time bears close resemblance to Ludwig Feuerbach’s critique in The Essence of Christianity, which had influenced the early Marx, of the inversion of collective humanity and the divine.
Литература
Arzuaga, Fabian (2019). “Socially necessary superfluity: Adorno and Marx on the crises of labor and the individual.” Philosophy and Social Criticism, 45, N 7: 819–843.
Bellofiore, Ricardo and Massimiliano Tomba (2014). The ‘Fragment on Machines’ and the Grundrisse: The workerist reading in question [2009]. In Beyond Marx: theorising the global labour relations of the twenty-first century, eds. Marcel Van der Linden and Karl Heinz Roth, 345-367. Leiden & Boston: Brill.
Benjamin, Walter (2003). On the concept of history. [1940]. In Selected Writings, Vol. 4: 1938-1940, eds. Howard Eiland and Michael W. Jennings, 389-411. Cambridge, Mass.: Belnap Press.
Benjamin, Walter (2021). Capitalism as religion. [1921]. In Toward the Critique of Violence: A Critical Edition, eds. Peter Fenves and Julia Ng, 90–92. Redwood City: Stanford University Press.
Bentham, Jeremy (1791). Panopticon: or, the inspection house. Dublin: Thomas Byrne.
Blumenfeld, Jacob (2014). “The abolition of time in Hegel’s ‘absolute knowing’ (and its relevance for Marx).” Idealistic Studies, 43, N 1 & 2,: 111–119.
Brown, Nathan (2019). “The revival of Hegelian Marxism: On Martin Hägglund’s This Life.” Radical Philosophy, 206: 34-42.
Bullinger, Heinrich (1849). The Decades, Vol. 1 [1577]. Ed. Rev. Thomas Harding, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Calvin, Jean (1846). Institutes of the Christian Religion, Vol. 2 [1535]. Trans. Henry Beveridge, Edinburgh: Calvin Translation Society.
Chalmers, Thomas (1808). An inquiry into the extent and stability of national resources. Edinburgh: Oliphant and Brown.
de Vivo, Giancarlo (2019). “Marx’s Pamphletist: Charles Wentworth Dilke and his tract on The Source and Remedy of the National Difficulties (1821).” Contributions to Political Economy 38: 59–73.
Dilke, Charles Wentworth (2019). The Source and Remedy of the National Difficulties, deduced from principles of political economy in a letter to Lord John Russell [1821]. Reprinted in Contributions to Political Economy, 38: 31-58.
Engels, Friedrich (1971). Preface to Capital: A critique of political economy. Vol. 2 [1893]. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Feuerbach, Ludwig (1845). The Essence of Christianity [1841]. Trans. Marian Evens, London: John Chapman.
Fleck, Amaro (2012). “A emancipação ociosa, ou, o que nos propõe a teoria crítica de Marx? (Idle emancipation, or, what does Marx's critical theory propose?)” Trans/Form/Ação, 35, N 1: 73-88.
Fromm, Erich (1951). The forgotten language: an introduction to the understanding of dreams, fairy tales, and myths, 241-49. New York: Rinehart & Co.
Godwin, William (1793). An Enquiry Concerning Political justice and its Influence on Morals and Happiness, Vol. 2. Dublin: Luke White.
Godwin, William (1823). The Enquirer. Reflections on Education, Manners, and Literature. In a Series of Essays [1797]. London: John Anderson.
Godwin, William (1831). Thoughts on Man: His Nature, Productions and Discoveries Interspersed with Some Particulars Respecting the Author. London: Effingham Wilson.
Godwin, William (1873). Essays Never Before Published, London: Henry S. King & Co.
Hägglund, Martin (2020). This Life: secular faith and spiritual freedom. New York: Anchor Books.
King, John (1983) “Utopian or scientific? A reconsideration of the Ricardian Socialists.” History of Political Economy, 15, N 3: 345-373.
Lapides Kenneth (2008). Marx’s wage theory in historical perspective: its origins, development, and interpretation. Tucson: Wheatmark.
Magun, Artemy (2003). “The Work of Leisure: The Figure of Empty Time in the Poetics of Hölderlin and Mandelshtam.” MLN, 118, N 5, Comparative Literature Issue: 1152-1176.
Magun, Artemy (2010). “Marx’s theory of time and the present historical moment.” Rethinking Marxism 22: 90–109.
Marx, Karl (1973a). Grundrisse. Foundations of the critique of political economy [1857-58]. Trans. Martin Nicolaus, Harmondsworth: Penguin.
Marx, Karl (1973b). Theories of Surplus Value, Part 3 [1861-63]. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Marx, Karl (1976). Capital, Vol. 1 [1867] Trans. Ben Fowkes, Harmondsworth: Penguin 1976.
Marx, Karl (2010). Letters from the Deutsch-Französische Jahrbüche: Marx to Ruge, Sept. 1843. In MECW, Vol. 3, page 144. Digital Edition: Lawrence & Wishart.
Musto, Marcello (2021). Alienation Redux: Marxian Perspectives. In Karl Marx’s Writings on Alienation, ed. Marcello Musto. Springer Nature.
Perkins, William (1626). A Treatise of the Vocations, or Callings of men, with the sorts and kinds of them, and the right use of them, [1605]. London: John Legatt.
Postone Moishe (1993). Time, Labor and Social Domination. New York: Cambridge University Press.
Reiner, Erwin (1964). “Some Remarks on Automation.” Science & Society, 28, N 4: 432-447.
Stafford, William (1980). “Dissenting Religion Translated into Politics: Godwin's Political Justice.” History of Political Thought, 1, N 2: 279-299.
Tomba, Massimiliano (2013). Marx's Temporalities. Trans. Peter D. Thomas and Sara R. Farris. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.
Walker, Tom (2021). “The Ambivalence of Disposable Time: The Source and Remedy of the National Difficulties at Two Hundred.” Contributions to Political Economy, 40: 80–90.
Weber, Max (1930). The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism [1904-05]. Trans. Talcott Parsons. New York: Charles Scribner & Sons.
