Comrade: The Zero-level of Communism

  • Jodi Dean
Keywords: сomrade, race, Communist Party, communism, Platonov, solidarity


Drawing from Andrei Platonov’s Chevengur, I present the figure of the comrade as the zero-level of communism. Platonov’s comrades persist in a postrevolutionary zone without workers, without classes, where the remainders of the old order have nothing but each other. Their condition of deprivation, where the persistence of each depends on the persistence of all, supplies the ground upon which to build communism. The comrade is the zero-level of communism because it designates the relation between those on the same side of the struggle to produce a new set of free, just, and equal social relations, relations without exploitation. Their relation is political, divisive. And it is intimate, intertwined with the sense of how desperately each depends upon the other if all are to persevere. I test this account of the comrade through the counter-intuitive case of the Communist Party of the United States. Although seemingly far removed from the Chevengurian communist project, the CPUSA nonetheless worked to establish the zero-level necessary for the communist movement: comradeship between black and white workers. At the basis of this comradeship was an understanding of racism as a condition of deprivation to be redressed through deprivation. Racism deprives the working class of solidarity. Solidarity requires that white workers deprive themselves of white privilege, the “wages of whiteness,” to use W.E.B. Dubois’s term. Hence, the Party focused, for a while, on establishing the zero-level of comradeship by devoting itself to the struggle for racial equality. If solidarity is possible, it is because the abolition of white supremacy leaves comrades to start anew.

Author Biography

Jodi Dean

Hobart and William Smith Colleges, Geneva, NY
300 Pulteney St, Geneva, NY, USA 14456


Bartholmes, Herbert (1970). Bruder, Bürger, Freund, Genosse. Gothenburg: Acta Universitatis Gothoburgensis.

“Black Belt Thesis” (2018). In Class Struggle and the Color Line, ed. Paul M. Heideman, 283–90. Chicago: Haymarket Books.

Briggs, Cyril V (2018a). “Bolshevism and Race Prejudice.” In Class Struggle and the Color Line, ed. Paul M. Heideman, 241. Chicago: Haymarket Books.

Briggs, Cyril V (2018b). “The Acid Test of White Friendship.” In Class Struggle and the Color Line, ed. Paul M. Heideman, 263–64. Chicago: Haymarket Books.

Chehonadskih, Maria (2017). “Soviet Epistemologies and the Materialist Ontology of Poor Life,” PhD Diss. Centre for Research in Modern European Philosophy, Kingston University, UK.

Garo, Isabelle (2017). “Chevengur, the Country of Unreal Communism — The October Revolution Through the Dialectical Art of Andréï Platonov.” Crisis and Critique 4.2: 174–96.

Gorky, Maxim (1905). “Comrade.” The Social Democrat X.8: 509–12. Marxist Internet Archive.

Haywood, Harry (1978). Black Bolshevik: Autobiography of an Afro-American Communist. Chicago: Liberator Press.

Jameson, Fredric (1994). The Seeds of Time. New York: Columbia University Press.

Kollontai, Alexandra (1977a). “Communism and the Family” [1920]. In Selected Writings of Alexandra Kollontai, trans. Alix Holt. Marxist Internet Archive.

Kollontai, Alexandra (1977b). “Sexual Relations and the Class Struggle” [1921]. In Selected Writings of Alexandra Kollontai, trans. Alix Holt. Marxist Internet Archive.

Kollontai, Alexandra (2006). “New Woman” [1918]. In The New Morality and the Working Class trans. Salvator Attansio. Marxist Internet Archive.

Magun Artemy (2013). Negative Revolution. London: Bloomsbury.

Platonov, Andrei (1978). Chevengur. Trans, Anthony Olcott. Ann Arbor, MI: Ardis Publishers.

Podoroga, Valery (1991). “The Eunuch of the Soul.” South Atlantic Quarterly 90: 2: 357–407.

Robinson, Cedric J. (2000). Black Marxism. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press.

Sitas, Ari (1992). “The Making of the ’Comrades’ Movement in Natal, 1985–1991.” 18. 3: 629–41.

Solomon, Mark (1998). The Cry Was Unity. Jackson: University of Mississippi Press.

Tomek, Beverly (2012). “The Communist International and the Dilemma of the American “Negro Problem”: Limitations of the Black Belt Self-Determination Thesis.” WorkingUSA: The Journal of Labor and Society 15: 549–76.

Trotsky, Leon (1940). “On Black Nationalism: Documents on the Negro Struggle.” Marxist Internet Archive negro1.htm#sd

Vinokur, G. O. (1929). Kul’tura iazyka [Language culture]. Moscow: Izdat. Federacija.

Wark, McKenzie (2015). Molecular Red. London: Verso.

Whitaker, Robert (2009). On the Laps of the Gods. New York: Three Rivers Press. Wilderson, Frank Samira Spatzek, and Paula von Gleich (2016). “’The Inside-Outside of Civil Society’: An Interview with Frank B. Wilderson, III.” Black Studies Papers 2.1: 4–22.

Žižek Slavoj (2013). Less Than Nothing. London: Verso.
How to Cite
Dean, J. (2018). Comrade: The Zero-level of Communism. Stasis, 6(2).
Thematic Articles

Most read articles by the same author(s)